I used to be a business planning expert. I wrote the books. Planning for Success. TENbizplan. Start Your Own Business, the workbook that became the standard in Ireland. In 2012, I wrote a blog post titled Business planning is pointless. My own books, I said, were no longer relevant. Too slow, too detailed, too much preparation for a world that moves in weeks, not years. Planning is guessing. Plans let the past drive the future.
Business planning is dead?
In 2016, working on the fourth edition of that same workbook, I changed my mind. Sort of. Business planning is dead, long live business planning. The rigid document was dead. The thinking behind it was more important than ever. Focus on movement, not detail. Define your operating parameters. Keep the vision in view. Both posts were wrong. And both were right. Which, as it happens, is the whole point of my new book, STOP PREDICTING.
Reinventing business planning
Last week, McKinsey published “Reinventing business planning with agentic AI”. It is nominally about sales and operations planning. Unpredictability is the issue. Beyond statistical forecast. How to include knowledge that the model does not know. Planning failure. A system that cannot see enough of the market.
Seven questions
Seven questions can help leaders understand where their planning organization stands today:
- In which area would better forecasting create the most value: inventory, service, production efficiency, or sourcing cost, and have we quantified it?
- Can our forecasting approach see anything outside our own history, and, if not, what is it structurally blind to?
- At what granularity do our planning decisions get made, and do we forecast at the same level or at a more or less aggregated level?
- Are our forecast horizons set by our physical lead times or by our reporting calendar?
- What share of our planners’ time goes to assembling data rather than exercising judgment, and where do we sit today between advisory AI and conditional autonomy?
- If the forecast improved by ten points tomorrow, which parameters, targets, and decision rights would have to change for that improvement to reach the balance sheet—and who owns them?
- When a planner overrides the system forecast, do we track whether the override improved accuracy?
Of their seven questions for leaders, question number two stands out for me: What is your forecast structurally blind to beyond its own history? That is the question I have been asking every day for three and a half years.
Stop predicting. Start sensing.
Between February 2023 and this year, I published more than 1,400 #MindCandy scenario prompts. STOP PREDICTING is what I learned from that experiment. Accuracy was never the goal. The value was in the habit: scanning widely, mixing signals that don’t obviously belong together, challenging assumptions, and building the reflex to act before disruption becomes obvious. Look at the McKinsey article through that lens:
- Mix the signals. Used-tyre search volume and freight costs predicting tyre demand is Lesson 1 in action. The signal that matters rarely comes from your own dashboard.
- The override is a weak signal. When a planner overrides the model, they are feeding in something the system can’t see. McKinsey’s last diagnostic question asks whether anyone tracks if those overrides actually improve accuracy. Most companies don’t. Most leaders don’t track their own predictions either. I did, 1,400 times. It is humbling. It is also the fastest way to learn.
- Calendar versus reality. McKinsey says forecast horizons should follow physical lead times, not the reporting calendar. Strategy is the same. Your annual plan exists because the board meets in Q4, not because the world changes on 1 January.
- Architecture beats accuracy. The real win is not a better forecast. It is redesigning decisions, roles and processes so the organisation responds faster. Bolt agents onto a bad process, McKinsey warns, and you just get a mediocre forecast quicker.
So is planning pointless?
In 2012, I wrote that 42% of the most successful entrepreneurial businesses had no plan. Fourteen years later, McKinsey reports that about 42% of organisations see no clear return from AI in planning. Same number. Same lesson. Technology doesn’t fix a planning mindset that assumes the future can be pinned down.
Here is where I have landed.
The plan is dead. The forecast as an answer is dead. What survives is the sensing system: the operating parameters of the Strategic Box, the habit of scanning, the discipline of being wrong, and adjusting fast. AI will do the assembly and the arithmetic. Your job is the judgment: when markets shift, customers surprise you, objectives collide, or a risk refuses to fit in a spreadsheet. The machines will predict. Leaders need to sense. Business planning is dead. Long live business sensing.